| | 55 | Emanuel Garcia | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Bronx | NY | Cardinal Spellman |
| | 56 | Codi Oliver | 5'11 | 2005 | PG | Bronx | NY | All Hallows |
| | 57 | Anthony Clark | 5'11 | 2005 | PG | Flushing | NY | Holy Cross | Committed-Broward Junior College |
| | 58 | Taskico Brown | 6'1 | 2005 | PG | New York | NY | Rice |
| | 59 | Jonathan Dorismond | 6'2 | 2005 | 2G | New York | NY | Justice Academy |
| | 60 | Moses Dayee | 5'10 | 2005 | PG | Staten Island | NY | New Dorp |
| | 61 | Scherau King | 6'4 | 2005 | PF | Staten Island | NY | Curtis |
| | 62 | Justin Bright | 6'0 | 2005 | PG | New York | NY | Park West |
| | 63 | Anthony Barnes | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Bronx | NY | Lehman |
| | 64 | Daniel Cox | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | Midwood |
| | 65 | Rondu Stevens | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | Cambria Heights | NY | Campus Magnet |
| | 66 | Jimmy Robertson | 6'1 | 2005 | 2G | New Rochelle | NY | Iona Prep |
| | 67 | Joseph Vines | 6'4 | 2005 | WF | New York | NY | Rice |
| | 68 | Chris Williams | 6'2 | 2005 | PG | Astoria | NY | St. John's Prep |
| | 69 | Keniel Henry | 6'3 | 2005 | 2G | Bronx | NY | Columbus |
| | 70 | Chris Lowery | 6'4 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | Xaverian |
| | 71 | Tim Hepworth | 6'1 | 2005 | 2G | Brooklyn | NY | Xaverian | Committed-Baruch |
| | 72 | Lawrence Alamilla | 6'4 | 2005 | PF | Brooklyn | NY | Lincoln |
| | 73 | Jameson Browne | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | Lafayette |
| | 74 | Arjan Perovic | 6'0 | 2005 | 2G | New York | NY | Future |
| | 75 | Kevin Cook | 6'0 | 2005 | 2G | Brooklyn | NY | McKinney |
| | 76 | Eren Savalsi | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | Tech |
| | 77 | Durrell Blacks | 6'1 | 2005 | 2G | Jamaica | NY | Edison |
| | 78 | Tramone Clark | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | Automotive |
| | 79 | Jonathan Chadwick Mye | 5'11 | 2005 | 2G | Staten Island | NY | Port Richmond |
| | 80 | Anthony Brown | 6'6 | 2005 | PF | Brooklyn | NY | Banneker |
| | 81 | Chris Noel | 5'7 | 2005 | PG | New York | NY | Wadleigh |
| | 82 | Melvin Clarida | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | Springfield Gardens | NY | Springfield Gardens |
| | 83 | Miro Fain | 6'1 | 2005 | 2G | New Rochelle | NY | Iona Prep |
| | 84 | Evaris Obas | 6'1 | 2005 | WF | New York | NY | La Salle |
| | 85 | Yeudy Vasquez | 6'0 | 2005 | 2G | New York | NY | Seward Park |
| | 86 | Ivan Rodriguez | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | New York | NY | Frederick Douglass |
| | 87 | Dominiq Singletary | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | New York | NY | Social Change |
| | 88 | Darren Townes | 6'5 | 2005 | PF | New York | NY | Manhattan Center |
| | 89 | Guy Miller | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Bronx | NY | Scanlan |
| | 90 | Maurice McNeil | 6'7 | 2005 | C | New York | NY | Seward Park |
| | 91 | James Marino | 5'10 | 2005 | 2G | New York | NY | Richard Green |
| | 92 | Ricardo St. Louis | 6'3 | 2005 | WF | New Rochelle | NY | Salesian |
| | 93 | Reginald Henson | 5'9 | 2005 | PG | Brooklyn | NY | Law Journalism & Researc |
| | 94 | Jeff Washington | 6'2 | 2005 | 2G | Staten Island | NY | Wagner |
| | 95 | Bernard Major | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | McKinney |
| | 96 | Paul Cline | 5'10 | 2005 | PG | Astoria | NY | Bryant |
| | 97 | Tsaiqua Bacon | 5'11 | 2005 | 2G | Brooklyn | NY | Middle College |
| | 98 | Devon Baker | 5'11 | 2005 | PG | Bronx | NY | Columbus |
| | 99 | Anthony Gilbert | 6'2 | 2005 | 2G | New York | NY | Fashion |
| | 100 | Jason Plenty | 5'10 | 2005 | PG | Queens Village | NY | Van Buren |
| | 101 | Chris Prizeman | 6'2 | 2005 | PF | Elmhurst | NY | Cathedral |
| | 102 | Ryan Eisner | 5'11 | 2005 | PG | Bayside | NY | Bayside | Committed-Drew |
| | 103 | Mamadou Fofana | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Bronx | NY | Morris |
| | 104 | Noel Mangan | 6'4 | 2005 | WF | New York | NY | Regis |
| | 105 | William Garvin | 5'8 | 2005 | PG | Bayside | NY | Bayside |
| | 106 | Kahlil McDonald | 6'1 | 2005 | 2G | Brooklyn | NY | Bishop Loughlin |
| | 107 | Jason Marchena | 5'10 | 2005 | PG | New York | NY | St. Agnes |
| | 108 | Terron Jones | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | New York | NY | La Guardia |
| | 109 | Terrell Hill | 5'9 | 2005 | PG | Bronx | NY | All Hallows |
| | 110 | Jakaria Thomas | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Brooklyn | NY | Bishop Ford |
| | 111 | Laquan Smith | 6'0 | 2005 | PG | New York | NY | Manhattan Village |
| | 112 | Damien Waller | 6'2 | 2005 | WF | Bronx | NY | Truman |
| | 113 | Jake Stevens | 5'9 | 2005 | PG | Brooklyn | NY | Xaverian |
| | 114 | Damian Mercado | 5'11 | 2005 | PG | Brooklyn | NY | Family Academy |
| | 115 | Brian Dennehy | 5'11 | 2005 | 2G | Bronx | NY | Fordham Prep |
| | HOOPSCOOP New York City Prep Report Page 2 |